If Fargo is the kind of thing you want more of, these 9 series are the closest matches in our catalogue. Each one links through to full details, ratings, cast and where to stream it.
1. American Crime Story (2016) 7.6
Linda Tripp navigates the treacherous waters of political scandal and media scrutiny in “American Crime Story,” where every word and whisper could make or break her reputation. As the truth unravels in this gripping crime drama, the lives of powerful figures like Hillary Clinton and Bill Clinton become entangled in a web of deceit and…
2. The Sinner (2017) 7.5
Harry Ambrose, a haunted detective tormented by his past, navigates the shadows of a small New York town as he investigates perplexing crimes that mirror his own inner turmoil.
3. DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story (2022) 8.0
Witness the shocking true story behind America’s most infamous serial killer. DAHMER – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story is a haunting and thought-provoking exploration of the dark forces that allowed one man to evade capture for years. This gripping drama shines a light on the failures that enabled a monster to thrive in plain sight.
4. Grimm (2011) 8.3
Meet Nick Burkhardt, a homicide detective with a secret: he’s the descendant of a legendary line of lawmen who can see and fight supernatural creatures lurking in the shadows of modern-day Portland. As he struggles to balance his duty to protect humanity with his new role as a Grimm, the lines between good and evil become increasingly…
5. Lanterns (2026) 8.3
In “Lanterns,” two legendary intergalactic officers—Hal Jordan and John Stewart—unite to solve a perplexing murder case in the American heartland, blending drama, mystery, and sci-fi intrigue as they navigate a dark secret that threatens their world.
6. Sharp Objects (2018) 7.8
Amy Adams stars as a troubled journalist who returns to her dark past in the haunting and atmospheric crime drama Sharp Objects, where the lines between truth and trauma blur. This gripping mystery follows Camille Preaker’s perilous investigation into two young girl murders that shook her small town years ago.
7. Dexter (2006) 8.2
Dexter Morgan navigates the delicate balance between his day job and his dark, personal crusade as a serial killer who targets other criminals. In a world where justice often falls short, he must stay one step ahead of both the law and those who seek to expose his secret life.
8. Chicago P.D. (2014) 8.4
District 21 is a city divided by duty and danger, where uniformed cops and intelligence officers fight side by side—and sometimes against each other—to protect Chicago’s toughest neighborhoods. Join Hank Voight as he navigates the complex web of loyalty and betrayal in the heart of District 21.
9. Defending Jacob (2020) 8.2
When a 14-year-old boy is charged with the brutal murder of his classmate, the tight-knit Barber family finds itself torn between loyalty and truth. As Chris Evans navigates the complexities of defending Jacob, viewers are drawn into a gripping drama that blurs the lines between innocence and guilt, making every twist more compelling…
Recommendations are drawn from TMDB’s similar-title data, then filtered to titles in the Cinemasm catalogue and ordered by audience size.